
16 Channel DVRs
www.benchmarkmagazine.com
30
presented. Whilst the Honeywell figure of
200ips isn’t incorrect, the specification doesn’t
mention the limitations on achieving the frame
rate. As such the unit falls into the mass of
basic DVRs with a cap of 50ips for 4CIF, 100ips
for 2CIF and 200ips for CIF. This is outside of
the base specification issued for the test, and
as such this does impact on the rating given.
One point to note is that Honeywell has
worked on the aesthetics of the HRDP16D. The
casing is black, and the lid has the Honeywell
logo pressed into it. Additionally, the fascia
includes a Honeywell logo which is illuminated
in red when the unit is powered up.
Whilst these points might seem trivial, the
reality is that they do give an impression of
quality to the end user. Given that some budget
models have basic stickers on the casing, and
sometimes obviously incorrect labelling, these
small touches are important. That said, in this
instance, we would have happily forgone the
frills for a bit more oomph!
The fascia is very much in line with a
standard DVR. There are a series of ten channel
select buttons, from 1 to 0, alongside basic
function buttons. There is also a four-way
button pad for menu navigation, which doubles
up as controls for playback control.
The HRDP16D is supplied with a full manual.
It’s comprehensive, but much of the
functionality is straightforward. The unit is also
supplied with an infrared remote control unit.
The menu structure is easy to use. Recording
configurations can be set on an individual
basis, with two screens – cameras 1 to 8, and 9-
16. General settings are simple, as is motion
detection and alarm handling. Search is also
easy to use.
The video settings allow resolution to be set
as 704 x 576 pixels, 704 x 288 pixels or 352 x
288 pixels; the only thing to watch is the
multiplication of frame rates, which occurs as
differing resolutions can be applied to
individual inputs. CIF images are displayed as
full screen, so there is slightly more pixilation.
There are four quality settings; Low, Normal,
High and Highest. With 4CIF recording, the High
and Highest settings deliver a clean image.
There are a few signs of compression,
dependent upon the viewed scene, but nothing
detrimental to the usability of the image. In
Normal mode, compression is more obvious,
but there isn’t a level of degradation that will
cause an issue. The Low setting show obvious
compression artefacting.
With CIF resolution, the image quality
deteriorates, and unless you are using High or
Highest the images are very obviously
compressed and only good enough for general
surveillance.
Mitsubishi DX-TL5716E
The Mitsubishi DX-TL5716E supports up to 16
video inputs with loop-throughs, with a variety
of video outputs. These are main monitor, and
spot monitor via BNC, as well as XGA and S-
Video outputs.
Other connections include 2 audio inputs
with 1 output, 16 alarm inputs, 16 relay outputs,
RS-485 and RS-232 data connections, a LAN
(10/100) port and 4 USB connections (two on
the front panel beneath a cover, and two on the
rear). A DVD rewriter is also included.
Other less usual options include a BNC input
and output for cascading multiple units, and a
selection of connections for tasks such as clock
synchronisation, event inputs, emergency
inputs, etc.. They could be useful, although
most machines will allow similar configurations
via basic alarm inputs.
Recorded video uses MPEG-4 compression
and resolutions can be set as 704 x 576 (4CIF),
704 x 288 (2CIF) or 352 x 288 (CIF). Record rate
is 400ips for CIF resolution, 200ips for 2CIF and
100ips for 4CIF.
The DX-TL comes from a generation of DVRs
where housings were heavy and robust. As
such, it’s a serious lump. The fascia is fairly
clean, with an array of indicator LEDs, a
jog/shuttle dial beneath which resides general
operational buttons, and channel select
options. Playback controls, set-up options and
the front mounted USB and video-out ports
(phono) are concealed beneath a flap.
The menu structure for the unit is pretty
straightforward, although you do get the
feeling that the unit could benefit from a rework
on the GUI. Setting features such as motion
detection and alarm handling is simple.
The video settings allow a choice of 4CIF, 2CIF
and CIF. There are also nine quality settings. At
Level 9 in 4CIF resolution, images are clear and
Mitsubishi DX-TL5716E
A no-frills dependable DVR
Starting to feel slightly out-dated
+
-
Samsung SRD1670DP
A genuine real-time DVR at all resolutions
A few more global options in the menus might be nice
+
-
Comentarios a estos manuales